Transition to the paid subscriber format

On April 2, 2012, The Tom Leykis Show was coming back to the air. Because of this Gary and Dino would have to dedicate more of their time to the Tom Leykis show and wouldn't be able to find the time to do a daily show. The pair decided to do a weekly show instead.

The transition that caused more controversy was the transition from a free show to adding a paywall to their show. Both Gary and Dino acknowledge that this caused the number listeners to the show to fall.